Wow, pretty harsh review. Maybe a little too skeptical, but given all the touting of the South Beach Diet on most other pages, the skepticism is refreshing, and I like how it references specific passages in the book to illustrate the point. Certainly food for thought!

This review states there is "faulty science, glaring nutrition inaccuracies, contraindications, etc" in this diet book. This review takes it one step further and actually lists the page numbers in the book where all of the above inaccuracies can be found. A refreshing change from the "this is a perfect diet" type link.